What kind of makeup should I buy if I want a natural, bronze-y look?

I recommend that you stick to Wet N Wild. I love their bronzers. They are high pigmented so don't go overboard, but they do last all day long and provide me a nice natural glow, and of course they are really cheap. You might really want to try their Mega Glo Illuminating powder. Its this circular bronze/blush makeup palette that features 4 shades that you can use as a highlighter, bronzer or blush. They are super blendable, and even double as eye shadows! I also recommend that you try their lipgloss in 563B Sun Glaze. It is a really super natural lipgloss.